When families think about college counseling, they often think about building college lists, developing extracurricular profiles, writing essays, and navigating application requirements and deadlines. These are all important parts of the process. But I believe some of the most valuable work happens well before any of these steps begin.
After more than 30 years working with college students as a professor, academic advisor, and dean, I've seen how much students benefit from understanding themselves: what genuinely interests them, what motivates them, how they engage with their education, the kinds of problems they care about and want to tackle, and the experiences that help them grow.
At Lantern College Counseling, we begin by getting to know students as individuals. We help them reflect on their interests and experiences, recognize connections they may not have noticed, and explore possibilities they may not have considered. We then help them translate those insights into meaningful opportunities for learning, exploration, and growth.
What does that look like in practice? I'd like to illustrate the process through examples drawn from my work with students. I've changed identifying details to protect their privacy.
Getting to Know the Student
Our College Admissions Counseling begins with listening. Before we start discussing college lists or application strategies, I want to understand who a student is, what they enjoy, what matters to them, and what they hope to gain from our work together.
One of the tools we use is a homegrown Passion Discovery Workbook, which invites students to reflect on their interests, experiences, values, and aspirations. We also use major and personality assessments to introduce additional perspectives and possibilities. Those reflections give us a starting point for finding meaningful extracurricular activities.
Some of the most revealing insights emerge from our conversations as we review the Passion Discovery Workbook together. I ask students to elaborate on their responses, probe their thinking, and encourage them to reflect more deeply. For example, a student might mention enjoying a chemistry lab. I'll ask what they particularly enjoyed about it. Was it the subject matter? The hands-on experimentation? Seeing scientific concepts come to life? Working with classmates? Taking the lead in solving a problem? The satisfaction of figuring out what went wrong when an experiment didn't work? Sometimes students haven’t considered these distinctions before. Their answers can reveal important clues about what motivates them and the kinds of experiences in which they thrive.
I listen not only to what students enjoy, but why. Sometimes seemingly unrelated interests reveal meaningful connections. Sometimes students discover that what they find most satisfying about an activity isn't what they initially thought. As we talk, I’m listening for threads that might be worth pulling. Together, we can weave those threads into more ambitious projects or find ways for students to make a greater contribution through activities they already care about.
Holding Up a Mirror
The following example is drawn from my work with a student. I've changed identifying details to protect the student's privacy.
When I began working with Sophie, she already had something many high school students lack: a remarkably clear vision of her future. She wanted to become an astronaut and had developed a detailed plan for how to get there. She assumed that studying aerospace or mechanical engineering was the natural next step.
Sophie is an exceptionally accomplished and ambitious young person. A strong student, she is active in athletics and music, and sets demanding goals for herself.
It would have been easy to focus our work on identifying excellent engineering programs and opportunities to strengthen her preparation. But as we explored her Passion Discovery Workbook together, I began to see something more interesting.
Sophie's intellectual curiosity is extraordinary in its breadth. She is fascinated by black holes, stars, the possibility of other universes, and the mysteries of space. She wonders about time travel, teleportation, cryosleep, and the strange implications of quantum mechanics. She has been reading about some of the most challenging ideas in modern physics. She is intrigued by the unexplored depths of the ocean and what might exist there that we have yet to discover.
Elsewhere in her reflections, Sophie raised questions about human civilization, including why people make choices that seem so inconsistent with our extraordinary capabilities. We talked about environmental destruction and human violence and discord. These questions and concerns emerged as she described what captured her attention and mattered to her.
As I listened, I began to see a larger pattern.
"You are fascinated by big questions and the mysteries of our world."
That observation captured something important about Sophie that her stated intention to study engineering did not.
She is drawn to the unknown. She wants to understand phenomena that challenge our current understanding, explore possibilities beyond what we already know, and grapple with questions that don't have straightforward answers. Some of those questions concern the physical universe. Others concern human behavior, society, and our responsibilities to one another.
What struck me was that Sophie had already identified engineering as her intended field of study without necessarily considering the many different ways she might pursue these interests. Engineering might be a wonderful fit, but so might physics, astronomy, or other scientific disciplines. The questions that fascinate her don't belong to any single field.
Her results from a major assessment reinforced the value of looking more broadly. The assessment suggested fields including environmental studies, health sciences, and decision sciences—but not engineering. I use assessments like this to help students discover fields they may never have considered.
Sophie had been thinking about her education primarily as a pathway toward becoming an astronaut. I wanted her to consider another question: What would she love learning about and doing along the way, regardless of where her ambitions ultimately take her?
I also wanted Sophie to understand that there is no single academic pathway to becoming an astronaut. I shared examples of astronauts whose educational backgrounds and careers took them in different directions, helping her see that engineering is one possibility among many. She could pursue her dream while exploring the subjects that most deeply engage her.
Sophie may ultimately decide that engineering is exactly right for her. But I hope she will make that choice with a richer understanding of herself and the opportunities available to her. Her ambition to become an astronaut can continue to guide her without limiting what she allows herself to discover along the way.
Helping Students Choose Meaningful Activities
Recognizing a student’s interests and motivations is an important first step. I then help students use those insights to find opportunities to explore their interests more deeply. To support this work, I've developed a comprehensive STEM Activities & Opportunities Guide that brings together academic programs, competitions, research opportunities, independent projects, and possibilities for leadership, mentoring, and community engagement. Although the guide has a STEM focus, many of its resources and suggestions are relevant to students with non-STEM interests.
My experience as a professor, academic advisor, and dean gives me a perspective that extends well beyond college admissions. I understand how academic disciplines intersect, how students develop their interests, and the many ways they can pursue meaningful learning experiences. I draw on that experience to help students identify and evaluate specific extracurricular activities, academic programs, projects, and other opportunities that build on their strengths and allow them to explore their interests more deeply.
For example, I worked with a student who was interested in engineering and enjoyed designing and building things. Through our conversations, I recognized that what particularly excited him was the iterative process of creating something, testing it, figuring out what wasn't working, and making improvements. Rather than suggesting that he add more engineering activities to his already busy schedule, I encouraged him to take an existing robotics project further, experimenting with modifications to the design and exploring ways to integrate additional capabilities. I also introduced him to fields such as mechatronics and human factors engineering, and recommended specific college engineering programs that emphasize hands-on design, prototyping, and interdisciplinary learning. I discuss how students can explore different engineering fields and compare college programs in my complete guide to choosing an engineering major.
Another student had interests that initially seemed quite disparate: current events, international affairs, debate, economics, and strategic games. As we talked, I began to recognize a common thread: he was fascinated by how complex systems work, how people make decisions, and how individual choices can produce larger consequences. I introduced him to fields such as game theory, behavioral economics, and political philosophy, which bring together several of these interests. I also recommended that he investigate a course in game theory and strategy to see whether he enjoyed studying these questions in a more structured academic setting.
These are just two examples of how our work moves from reflection to action. My recommendations might involve a particular summer program, an academic course, a research opportunity, an independent project, a book, or a conversation with someone working in a field that interests the student. As students explore these possibilities, I help them evaluate their options, determine next steps, and reflect on what they're learning about themselves along the way.
An equally important part of our approach is encouraging students to take ownership of these explorations. Sometimes that means pursuing an opportunity we've identified together. Other times, it means developing an idea of their own, seeking out a mentor, or creating an opportunity that doesn't already exist. Not every exploration leads to a lasting interest, and that's part of the value of the process. Discovering that something isn't quite what a student expected can be just as informative as discovering a new passion.
Over time, students develop a richer understanding of themselves. They begin to recognize that they have considerable agency in shaping their experiences, both in high school and, eventually, in college.
Why Self-Discovery Matters for College Admissions—and Beyond
When students have a deeper understanding of their interests, motivations, and aspirations, they are better equipped to make thoughtful decisions about college. In our Deep-Fit™ admissions approach, that self-knowledge helps students look beyond rankings and reputation and consider which academic programs, learning environments, communities, and opportunities will help them thrive.
This understanding can also strengthen their applications. Students who have reflected deeply on their experiences and pursued interests that genuinely engage them are often better prepared to articulate who they are, what matters to them, and what they hope to contribute to a college community. Their applications can tell a more authentic and coherent story because that story emerges from their actual experiences and choices.
But the value of this work extends well beyond admission. Throughout my career in higher education, I've seen students flourish when they take an active role in shaping their education. Finding mentors, exploring unfamiliar subjects, building relationships, pursuing opportunities, and navigating setbacks all require curiosity, initiative, and self-awareness. Through the Deep-Fit™ Framework, I help students develop agency during the college search so they can exercise it once they’re on campus.
Ultimately, the goal isn't simply to help students get into college. It's to prepare them to make the most of the opportunities that lie ahead.